Legislation calls for more scrutiny of nursing home deaths

November 29, 2010 | | Comments 8
State Rep. Tom Burch, D-Louisville

State Rep. Tom Burch, D-Louisville


By Valarie Honeycutt Spears –

An overhaul of the system for investigating deaths in Kentucky nursing homes is proposed in a bill pre-filed by state Rep. Tom Burch, D-Louisville, for the 2011 General Assembly.

Central to Burch’s legislation is a provision that would require a specific staff member at long-term care facilities and hospices to report all deaths to the county coroner within 24 hours.

BR 67 also requires coroners to involve police or prosecutors if they suspect maltreatment. But Burch said Monday the bill is intended to give coroners discretion in choosing which deaths need review by other officials.

Currently, state law does not require nursing homes to report most deaths to coroners, who are rarely called even when abuse or neglect is suspected.

Burch’s proposal acts on recommendations made by Gov. Steve Beshear’s administration following an internal review earlier this year of how nursing home abuse and neglect allegations are investigated. The review came after the Herald-Leader published a series of reports this summer about gaps in the system used to investigate nursing home abuse.

The newspaper found that from 2007 to 2009, 18 deaths resulted in Type A citations — those issued by the Cabinet when a resident’s life or safety has been endangered. As of early July, 15 of the deaths had not been prosecuted, and three deaths were considered to be open investigations.

Prosecutors and law enforcement officers polled as part of Beshear’s review said it would be helpful to their investigations if coroners were called about nursing home deaths. Attorney General Jack Conway, whose recommendations were sought for the review, contacted prosecutors who said they never had a death case from a nursing home in which an autopsy had been performed.

Conway has said a current provision that requires caregivers to notify coroners about a death from any cause “other than natural” leaves nursing homes with broad discretion on reporting a case of potential abuse or neglect. Oftentimes, state investigators don’t know that a death might have been caused by abuse or neglect until a family member or another individual makes a complaint.

Burch, chairman of the state House Health and Welfare Committee, said he expects his bill will be fine-tuned in coming months. For example, he noted that the legislation calls for deaths that occur in hospice facilities for terminally ill patients to be reported to the coroner. He said hospices were included in an effort “to cover all the bases.”

Officials with the Kentucky Association of Health Care Facilities could not immediately be reached for comment about the proposal.

Fayette County Coroner Gary Ginn said Monday that there were 531 nursing home deaths in Fayette County in 2009 and 9,374 across the state.

Ginn said he wanted to compare the provisions of the bill against the checks and balances now in state law before taking a position on the proposal. But he said he was concerned that coroners could be notified anytime within the first 24 hours instead of at the time of death.

If a nursing home waits 24 hours to notify the coroner, the body of a resident could already be at a mortuary and embalmed, Ginn said.

In cases when a resident dies after being transferred to a hospital from the facility, the bill would require the nursing home or hospice to report the death within 24 hours of being notified of the death.

All nursing homes would have to give the Attorney General’s office the name of a specific employee whose job it is to report to the coroner or be fined $200 for each week that the nursing home didn’t comply.

A designated employee who failed to contact the coroner would face criminal penalties.

The bill also strengthens the criminal penalty for failing to report abuse and neglect of an adult from a Class B misdemeanor, punishable by up to 90 days in jail and up to a $250 fine, to a Class A Misdemeanor, which calls for up to 12 months imprisonment and a fine of up to $500.

The legislation calls for specific training on abuse and neglect for nursing home staff and nursing home inspectors and requires the Attorney General to establish a Kentucky Multidisciplinary Commission on Adult Abuse and Neglect. The commission would define the procedures for investigating adult abuse and neglect deaths in long-term care facilities.

Also, every death where abuse and neglect is suspected would have to be investigated by a local multidisciplinary team that includes at least one law enforcement officer and a staff member from the Cabinet for Health and Family Services.

Currently, a state regulation requires a nursing home to notify the physician and the family whenever a resident’s status changes. If there is a suspicion of abuse or neglect, the nursing home administrator is required to report the death or injury to the Cabinet for Health and Family Services Office of Inspector General, which investigates.

The inspector general or Adult Protective Services office — both of which are part of the cabinet — can notify local police or prosecutors when criminal activity is suspected. A family member can ask for an investigation by the OIG, the county coroner or local police.

Filed Under: KY General AssemblySocial ServicesState GovernmentSteve BeshearTom Burch

About the Author: Valarie Honeycutt Spears is a Lexington native and a graduate of Transylvania University. A Lexington Herald-Leader reporter since1983, she covers a wide range of topics including government.

RSSComments (8)

Leave a Reply | Trackback URL

  1. daniel says:

    I would only allow the bill to say the coroner is to be notified before the body may be disposed by incineration. Now you may have a problem with timing and how to pay for this.

  2. […] this link: Legislation calls for more scrutiny of nursing home deaths … Comments […]

  3. […] more: Legislation calls for more scrutiny of nursing home deaths … Related Posts:Owner: 5 NC nursing home deaths under scrutiny – NewsPlurk AP MOUNT OLIVE, NC […]

  4. Buck Feshear says:

    My father died in a nursing home earlier this year. He had been in declining health for a couple of years and there was nothing at all suspicious about his death, but the doctor on staff merely listed the cause of his death as “sudden death” on his death certificate. Well, duh! Death usually is sudden. What should have been documented was what caused that sudden death. Heart attack? Stroke? Resperatory failure? Aneurism?

  5. Good post! Thanks for your information! ,ASICS Running shoes,Onitsuka Shoes-ASICS Tiger shoes
    Shop for Onitsuka Tiger,ASICS Shoes,Asics Tiger Shoes from range of Onitsuka Tiger Shoes for Men and Women,Free Shipping!

  6. what nice post,thank you for sharing